Impact analysis · Dutch National Opera & Ballet

Theory of Flames: environmental impact of AI decor and LED screens

A greenhouse-gas inventory of the AI decor of the opera Theory of Flames (Dutch National Opera & Ballet, 2025–2026 season): electricity for AI content creation, LED screens in operation, inbound transport and the materials embodied in the LED hardware, calculated in five reporting scenarios with eco-costs as a supplementary indicator. The calculator behind the study is available as an open, anonymised model for the performing arts sector.

Download the report (PDF) Go to the calculator

Topics on this page
GHG ProtocolScope 3LCAEco-costsTheatre Green BookCritical raw materials
7,373.7
kg CO₂e for the decor in scenario B: renewable electricity, shared use of a new LED asset
−5.6%
effect of renewable electricity on the total (scenario B versus A)
78.7%
share of the LED hardware itself (embodied materials) in scenario B
5
reporting scenarios (A–E) for the same decor
Case

What the study did

Dutch National Opera & Ballet measures the environmental impact of new productions. For Theory of Flames, an opera in which AI-generated images and video on LED screens form the decor, the opera house asked for a substantiated estimate of the impact of that decor. The central research question: what is the environmental impact of the decor of Theory of Flames, in kg CO₂e, including AI computing and LED screens (production and use), and which measures reduce that impact?

The study is a greenhouse-gas inventory of the current production. The unit of analysis runs from September 2025 to March 2026 and covers AI content creation by DoubleA, LED decor build and testing, rehearsals and 5 performances. The final calculation with scenario analysis and improvement priorities is reporting model v2.0 of April 2026. The public edition of the report and the open calculator date from September 2026.

Scope

Scope and method

The system boundary is the current production (current-production boundary). The inventory is informed by the GHG Protocol Product Life Cycle Accounting and Reporting Standard, without a formal conformance claim: it is not a full cradle-to-grave product inventory. No offsets, credits or avoided emissions are included. Eco-costs are reported separately as a supplementary single-indicator screening; the circularity bridge follows the wording of Theatre Green Book v2 Basic and applies only to the on-stage LED asset.

Unit of analysis and system boundary: the current modeled Theory of Flames AI decor production boundary for Sep 2025 – Mar 2026, covering AI content creation, LED decor build/testing, rehearsals and 5 performances. This model includes in Scenario B the re-use of the LED-decor across the following confirmed rehearsals and performances of the production Theory of Flames, but excludes the re-use of the LED-decor for new productions beyond Theory of Flames.

Clarification on allocation: Scenarios A, B and D attribute 20 per cent of the durable LED hardware to this production as a shared-use proxy, equal to one of five expected production-equivalent uses of the asset over its reference service life. No electricity, transport or operation of any production beyond Theory of Flames is included in the inventory. The fully dedicated single-production case is reported separately as Scenario C.

The model keeps three layers apart: operational electricity use, purchased transport and embodied hardware and materials. Scope 1 is zero (no direct combustion modelled); Scope 2 is the electricity for LED operation in the venue; Scope 3 covers the external electricity for AI content creation, the LED hardware as a capital good, packaging and transport. In scenario A the split Scope 1 / 2 / 3 is 0.0 / 288.5 / 7,526.0 kg CO₂e.

ComponentWhat is calculatedIndicator
Operational electricity – AI content creationkWh of the local AI workstations × the applied electricity factorCO₂ and eco-cost
Operational electricity – LED operationPower per m² at the brightness used × area × active hours per phase, plus standbyCO₂ and eco-cost
Purchased transport – inbound new LED assetCounted only when the purchase status is ‘new purchase’CO₂ and eco-cost
Embodied materials – packaging and durable LED hardwareProxy per m² until a supplier PCF or EPD is available; allocation of the hardware to this productionCO₂ and eco-cost
AI local hardware and cloud or API servicesLower-bound proxiesEco-cost only
Circularity and end of lifePrevious and future life of the LED asset; bridge to Theatre Green Book v2 BasicStatus (meets / does not meet)

Source: report, ‘Method basis and comparison restrictions’. Eco-costs follow the eco-costs method (ecocostsvalue.com): a prevention-cost indicator in euros, not project spend.

Scenarios

The five scenarios

The model calculates the same decor in five reporting scenarios. Two settings make the difference: the applied electricity factor (grid electricity 0.258 kg CO₂e/kWh or renewable electricity 0.000 kg CO₂e/kWh, applied to all project electricity) and the allocation of the newly purchased LED asset to this production (20% for shared use, 100% for a dedicated asset, 0% for existing stock). Scenario D adds a 20% embodied-materials completeness adjustment as a conservative sensitivity case. The LED reference service life is 7.5 years in all scenarios.

ScenarioDescriptionTotal CO₂ (kg CO₂e)Eco-cost (€)Theatre Green Book Basic (LED asset)
AGrid electricity / shared-use new LED hardware asset (20% allocated)7,814.51,843.6Does not meet – previous life below threshold
BRenewable electricity / shared-use new LED hardware asset (20% allocated)7,373.71,739.2Does not meet – previous life below threshold
CRenewable electricity / dedicated new LED hardware asset (100% allocated)30,597.67,976.8Does not meet – previous life and future life below threshold
DRenewable electricity / shared-use new LED hardware asset + embodied-materials completeness adjustment (+20%)8,549.02,052.3Does not meet – previous life below threshold
ERenewable electricity / existing reusable LED hardware asset (0% allocated)0.016.9Potentially meets thresholds for on-stage LED asset; evidence incomplete

Source: report, table ‘Scenario comparison overview’ (reporting model v2.0). CO₂ in kg CO₂e; eco-cost in € as an environmental indicator, not project spend. The scenarios are comparable only with each other: same activity base, same unit of analysis, same model structure.

Results

Key results

The hotspot is the hardware, not the AI. In all new-purchase scenarios the LED hardware itself (embodied materials) is the dominant item: 5,806.0 kg CO₂e in scenarios A, B and D (74.3%, 78.7% and 67.9% of the scenario total) and 29,029.8 kg CO₂e in scenario C (94.9%). Inbound transport of the new asset weighs 1,497.6 kg CO₂e (19.2% in A). Electricity for AI content creation weighs 152.2 kg CO₂e (1.9%) in scenario A and LED operation 288.5 kg CO₂e (3.7%).

ComponentScenario A: kg CO₂e (share)Scenario B: kg CO₂e (share)
Operational electricity use – AI content creation152.2 (1.9%)0.0 (0.0%)
Operational electricity use – LED operation288.5 (3.7%)0.0 (0.0%)
Purchased transport – inbound new LED asset1,497.6 (19.2%)1,497.6 (20.3%)
Embodied materials – LED purchase packaging70.2 (0.9%)70.2 (1.0%)
Embodied materials – durable LED hardware asset5,806.0 (74.3%)5,806.0 (78.7%)
Total7,814.57,373.7

Source: report, ‘CO₂ emissions breakdown’ tables for scenarios A and B.

Renewable electricity helps, but does not remove the materials hotspot. Scenario B isolates the electricity-factor change versus scenario A: −440.7 kg CO₂e (−5.6%) and −104.4 eco-cost. The hotspot remains the LED hardware; renewable electricity does not neutralise the critical-material question of LED decor.

Allocation drives the spread. When the asset is attributed entirely to one production (scenario C), the total rises to 30,597.6 kg CO₂e and 7,976.8 eco-cost. In the Theatre Green Book bridge this case fails both the previous-life and the future-life criteria. Scenario D shows what a conservative completeness adjustment does: +1,175.2 kg CO₂e versus B, shown as a separate line so the base component values remain visible.

Model zero is not impact-free. Scenario E (existing, reusable asset) scores 0.0 kg CO₂e within this boundary because no new-purchase burden is attributed; eco-cost remains 16.9 because electricity, AI local hardware and cloud or API services still carry burden. If a newly purchased asset is used more often, the per-production burden falls through allocation; that logic is closer to scenario B than to E.

No comparison with a non-electronic decor. The study does not model a non-AI counterfactual. Whether a craft-oriented, more durable, repairable or transferable set could have delivered the same artistic service remains a design discussion, not a quantified result.

Source: report, ‘Primary decision messages’, the interpretation per scenario and ‘Craft-oriented, durable, repairable and transferable alternatives’.

Electricity

Electricity in perspective

The electricity note in the report places the model values next to household references. One active hour of the LED decor uses 4.10 kWh; one AI machine-hour 1.25 kWh; with both AI workstations active at the same time, one clock hour is about 2.50 kWh. One performance of 1.75 hours uses 7.18 kWh and the 5 performances together 35.88 kWh. One active LED hour therefore sits above one AI machine-hour and above one clock hour with both AI workstations active. For reference: 1 kWh equals 16.7 hours of a 60 W incandescent bulb.

Use caseTimeElectricity (kWh)
Laptop, normal work1 hour0.005–0.020
Laptop, heavy work / local AI / rendering1 hour0.030–0.070
Electric kettle, 0.5 litre3 min0.10
Vacuum cleaner10 min0.15
Electric oven30 min2.00
AI content creation for the decor1 machine-hour1.25
Both AI workstations at the same time1 clock hour2.50
LED decor in build, testing or rehearsal1 active LED hour4.10
One performance1.75 hours7.18
5 performances in total5 × 1.75 hours35.88

Source: report, ‘Electricity note’. The comparison is directional, not metered; the rehearsal row uses the active LED-hour rate as a proxy. Across the whole unit of analysis the reporting model counts 590 kWh for AI content creation and 1,118.3 kWh for LED operation.

Traffic light

Critical raw materials

The LED panels contain critical raw materials. The model screens five material families qualitatively (traffic light), cross-checked against European Commission and JRC sources on critical and strategic raw materials. Outcome: 2 red, 3 orange. A quantified, mass-based assessment is not yet possible while trace masses, sourcing region and recovery route are missing.

Material familyStatusInterpretationNext step
GalliumRedFunctional semiconductor input in the LED chip layer; exact trace mass and sourcing are unknown in the current model.Ask supplier for chip chemistry, trace mass, sourcing region and recovery route.
Rare earth elementsRedRare-earth family is present, but exact phosphor chemistry and mass share are not documented.Ask supplier which REEs are used in phosphors and in what trace quantities.
CopperOrangeLikely meaningful mass share and potentially recoverable, but recycled content and mass split are not evidenced.Request copper mass share, recycled content and formal recovery route.
Aluminium / alumina familyOrangeLarge mass family with strong embodied relevance; circularity and recycled content matter more than trace presence alone.Confirm alloy mass, recycled content and durable re-use / recycling route.
IndiumOrangeTrace display material with relevance for LED and electronics chains; current EU criticality status is weaker than gallium and rare earths.Ask supplier for ITO trace mass and coating chemistry.

Source: report, table ‘Critical materials screening’. More on the approach: Critical raw materials.

Terms of use

Limitations and terms of use

The report carries the release gate Conditional – internal use only / not audit-ready and the fit-for-use status Directional / internal decision support, with a weighted QA score of 0.766 on a scale of 0 to 1 and 1 blocking, 2 major and 2 medium open data points. The QA score weighs the completeness and evidence quality of the inputs; the open flags relate to the first three improvement priorities below. The public edition is shared for learning in the performing arts sector, not as an audit-ready external disclosure.

In concrete terms: the embodied LED layer is proxy-based because no supplier PCF or EPD and no reviewed bill of materials with masses is available; AI local hardware and cloud or API services are lower-bound proxies; the Theatre Green Book bridge is limited to the on-stage LED asset and is not a full production-level assessment; the scenarios are comparable only within this set and this unit of analysis. The study makes no broader environmental superiority claim.

The same applies to anyone using the calculator: results are directional for design, procurement and re-use decisions. External claims require stronger supplier and provider evidence.

Source: report, ‘Governance and evidence context’ and ‘Limitations, allowed use and next improvements’.

Next steps

Six improvement priorities

Within the unit of analysis, the first priority is better supplier evidence for the LED hardware, followed by stronger AI hardware and cloud evidence and a documented re-use or WEEE route.

PriorityTopicMain data still needed
1Supplier PCF / EPD / BOMSupplier PCF or EPD, or a panel-level bill of materials with material masses.
2AI hardware and cloud evidenceJob logs, provider region, machine lifetimes, utilisation and PUE evidence.
3Circularity and end-of-life routeFormal re-use plan, return route, WEEE or recycling route and any refurbishment assumptions.
4LED operational electricity meteringMeasured power and active hours by phase.
5Critical material trace massesTrace masses, sourcing region and recovery evidence for gallium, indium, rare earths, copper and the aluminium family.
6AI provider and machine choiceProvider region, model type, machine class, datacentre efficiency and the quality of the renewable-electricity evidence.

Source: report, table ‘Limitations, allowed use and next improvements’ (without the owner column).

Origin

Origin and licence

Developed by New Economy for Dutch National Opera & Ballet for the production Theory of Flames (season 2025–2026). The AI content was created by DoubleA. The study used the GHG Protocol Product Standard as guidance (Scope 1/2/3), Theatre Green Book v2 Basic for the circularity bridge, European Commission and JRC sources for critical raw materials and the eco-costs method of ecocostsvalue.com. The public edition is based on the final reporting model v2.0 (April 2026); personal data, contact details and supplier details have been left out, while the calculation logic and the A–E scenario structure are unchanged.

Report: © New Economy, commissioned by Dutch National Opera & Ballet. Sharing and citing with attribution permitted. The calculator behind the study is available as an open model: AI decor and LED calculator: calculate the CO₂ impact of a digital set.

Report and calculator

The report is in English; the Dutch project page summarises the key points in Dutch.

Insights

Insights from the study

Source-bound insights from the greenhouse-gas inventory of the AI decor: scenario figures, hotspots, eco-costs and critical raw materials.

From this project

Citable insights

Figures, observations and recommendations from Theory of Flames: environmental impact of AI decor and LED screens. Free to use under CC BY 4.0, with attribution.

All insights

Frequently asked questions

What is the environmental impact of the AI decor of Theory of Flames?

In the main reference scenario (B: renewable electricity, shared use of a new LED asset) the decor comes to 7,373.7 kg CO₂e and 1,739.2 eco-cost. With grid electricity (scenario A) the total is 7,814.5 kg CO₂e; when the asset is attributed entirely to one production (scenario C) it is 30,597.6 kg CO₂e. An existing, reusable asset (scenario E) counts 0.0 kg CO₂e and 16.9 eco-cost within this boundary. Source: report, table ‘Scenario comparison overview’.

Why is the LED hardware the largest hotspot rather than the AI?

Because the materials in the LED asset weigh more than the electricity use. In scenario A the durable LED hardware is 5,806.0 kg CO₂e (74.3% of the total) and inbound transport 1,497.6 kg CO₂e (19.2%), against 152.2 kg CO₂e (1.9%) for AI content-creation electricity and 288.5 kg CO₂e (3.7%) for LED operation. In scenario C the hardware share rises to 94.9%. Source: report, ‘CO₂ emissions breakdown’ tables for scenarios A and C.

What does renewable electricity change?

Scenario B isolates the electricity-factor change versus scenario A: total CO₂ falls by 440.7 kg CO₂e (−5.6%) and eco-cost by 104.4. The hotspot remains the LED hardware; a better electricity factor does not remove the materials question. Source: report, ‘Primary decision messages’ and the scenario B interpretation.

What does 0.0 kg CO₂e in scenario E mean?

It is a model result, not an impact-free reality. In scenario E the LED asset is already present, so no new-purchase burden (hardware, packaging, inbound transport) is attributed within this boundary. Eco-cost remains 16.9 because electricity, AI local hardware and cloud or API services still carry burden. If a newly purchased asset is used more often, the per-production burden falls through allocation; that logic is closer to scenario B than to E. Source: report, scenario E interpretation.

What are eco-costs and why are they reported next to CO₂?

Eco-costs are a supplementary environmental indicator in euros: the prevention cost of avoiding the environmental burden, not project spend and not a carbon footprint. The report splits them into human health, nature, resource scarcity and carbon; in scenario B respectively 51.3 / 175.3 / 537.1 / 975.4 of a total of 1,739.2. Renewable electricity still carries eco-cost burden while its CO₂ factor is 0.000 kg CO₂e/kWh. Source: report, ‘Reading guide’ and scenario B headline results.

Which critical raw materials are in the LED panels?

The screening puts gallium and rare earth elements on red and copper, aluminium/alumina and indium on orange. For all five, trace masses, sourcing region and recovery route are still missing; the first step is to request those data from the supplier. Source: report, table ‘Critical materials screening’.

How reliable are the results?

The report carries the fit-for-use status ‘Directional / internal decision support’ and the release gate ‘Conditional – internal use only / not audit-ready’, with a weighted QA score of 0.766 on a scale of 0 to 1. The embodied LED layer is proxy-based because no supplier PCF or EPD is available, AI hardware and cloud are lower-bound proxies and the scenarios are only comparable with each other. The study makes no broader environmental superiority claim. Source: report, ‘Governance and evidence context’ and ‘Limitations, allowed use and next improvements’.

Who can use the calculator and what does it cost?

Companies, producers, theatres and set designers who want to estimate the CO₂ impact of a digital set. The calculator is the anonymised version of the reporting model behind this study, is shared with the performing arts sector on the initiative of Dutch National Opera & Ballet and is free to use under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 (CC BY 4.0). The workbook is an Excel file in English, with a bilingual explanation on the first tab.

Practical questions

Frequently asked questions about the report and its scope

Is the report available in Dutch?

No. The report is written in English; the Dutch project page summarises the key points in Dutch. The calculator has a bilingual first tab (Dutch and English).

Which period and which activities does the study cover?

The unit of analysis runs from September 2025 to March 2026 and covers AI content creation, LED decor build and testing, rehearsals and 5 performances.

What is a ‘current-production boundary’?

The system boundary is the current production: what was made, purchased and used for this decor. It is not a full cradle-to-grave product inventory, which is why the report makes no formal conformance claim to the GHG Protocol Product Standard.

Does the study include offsets or avoided emissions?

No. Offsets, credits and avoided emissions are not included. The figures show attributed emissions and eco-costs within the chosen boundary.

What does the Theatre Green Book status in the scenario table mean?

The bridge to Theatre Green Book v2 Basic tests only the on-stage LED asset for a previous life and a future life. A newly purchased asset has no previous life in the bridge and therefore does not meet the threshold; an existing asset (scenario E) potentially meets it, but the evidence is incomplete. It is not an assessment of the whole production.

May the report be shared or cited?

Yes, with attribution: © New Economy, commissioned by Dutch National Opera & Ballet. The report is directional and intended for scenario comparison and decision support, not as an audit-ready disclosure.

Further reading

Related footprint and materials work

Model structure, formulas, texts and questionnaire: New Economy, Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 (CC BY 4.0). Idemat 2026 factor values: © Sustainable Impact Metrics Foundation / TU Delft, CC BY-NC (not for commercial LCA or CSRD software), source ecocostsvalue.com. Attribution: ‘New Economy, AI decor and LED impact model v2.0 (CC BY 4.0)’. Case data: with the consent of Dutch National Opera & Ballet, as an example only. Report: © New Economy, commissioned by Dutch National Opera & Ballet; sharing and citing with attribution permitted.

Questions about the study or a calculation of a production

Questions about the study, the report or a calculation for a production go to New Economy.

Email New Economy
Scroll to Top