The interpretation section of the study of the AI decor of Theory of Flames (Dutch National Opera & Ballet, reporting model v2.0, April 2026) sets an explicit claim limit for scenarios A and B: do not claim that renewable electricity neutralises the material-criticality issue. The electricity factor only touches operational electricity; the critical materials sit in the chips, phosphors, conductors and frames of the LED panels.
The figures bear this out. From scenario A to B, 440.7 kg CO₂e (−5.6%) disappears, while the hardware layer stays unchanged at 5,806.0 kg CO₂e and the eco-costs for resource scarcity move from 540.8 to 537.1. Gallium and rare earth elements remain red, copper, aluminium/alumina and indium orange.
According to the report, a shared new asset is only more defensible than a dedicated one (100%) if durable re-use, repair, recovery and supplier evidence are credible. For existing stock (scenario E) the question shifts to stewardship: maintenance, verified previous life and a documented next life.
The recommendation for the performing arts: buy renewable electricity and keep material demand small, with less new hardware, longer service life and an arranged recovery route.
Source: study of the AI decor of Theory of Flames (Dutch National Opera & Ballet, reporting model v2.0, April 2026), New Economy. Part of the project Theory of Flames: environmental impact of AI decor and LED screens.
